Newsday Penalized For Selling Links

Link Building Add comments
Estimated reading time: 2 minutes, 23 seconds

The popular Long Island New York newspaper Newsday was penalized by Google for selling text links that pass pagerank.

Here is a screenshot of the crazy amount of nofollow tags used by Newsday.com

newsday

There are nearly 100 no followed links, but it’s quite curious to see which links are still passing PR. Semi related links to small local destination sites are still getting a link boost from this PageRank 8 site including a wedding, travel, health and shopping site.

Links that are directly related to this large print publication including the LA Times, Baltimore Sun, Orlando Sentinel and other huge newspapers are nofollowed.

The archive shows a section labeled ‘ Featured Links’ which carry sites such as :

  • Mesothelioma Lawyer Lung Cancer
  • Personal Injury Law Firm
  • Buy Mets Tickets
  • Buy Yankees Tickets
  • Wicked Tickets
  • Hamptons Travel

So Newsday.com can boost its fledgling sites while trying to negate the association of major newspapers, and the Hamptons Travel site is still linking with full credit. Hey newsday, i’ll sell you one of my content sites so your PR8 site can link to it and we can dominate the SERP’s.

Google has always been inconsistent in dealing with link sellers. There seems to be no complete method to find out which sites will receive a penalty for selling links that pass page rank. Google has not algorithmically solved the problem of link brokering and must rely on a semi accurate computer model with heavy human intervention.

Loren, WPN, Barry posted about this interesting case.

*update*

The SEO Manager, who was hired after the link selling program was implemented, posted a request in Google Groups and apparently got the problem resolved within 1 week. Newsday.com instantly jumped from a toolbar PR 5 to 8.

Google Engineer Reid

Thanks for your post. I’m glad you’re posting here in the Webmaster
Help Group, because the discussions here help educate webmasters
around the globe. I just checked over newsday.com and compared it to
the most recent version of newsday.com that was indexed by
Archive.org:
http://web.archive.org/web/20070829225145/http://www.newsday.com/

Scrolling near the bottom of what your site used to look like, I see
the following “Featured Links”:
Mesothelioma Lawyer Lung Cancer Personal Injury Law Firm
Buy Mets Tickets Buy Yankees Tickets Wicked Tickets
Hamptons Travel

Please remember that participating in link schemes intended to
manipulate search engine rankings, including buying or selling links
that pass PageRank, is a violation of our Webmaster Guidelines, and
may impact your site’s standing in Google:
http://www.google.com/support/webmasters/bin/answer.py?answer=66356

If you believe your site was at one point in violation of the
Webmaster Guidelines, and you have since made changes to your site so
that it fits within the guidelines, you can request reconsideration of
your site by following the steps here:
http://www.google.com/support/webmasters/bin/answer.py?answer=35843

Tags: , , ,

17 Responses to “Newsday Penalized For Selling Links”

  1. Brent D. Payne Says:

    You may want to update your screenshot. I added another dozen nofollows. I left the other links open due to either inability for me to edit the code on the fly or because we own the sites and I see nothing wrong with linking to a site we own.

    I will talk with the design team tomorrow though about why we even have the site index box at the bottom of the page. I nofollowed them a while ago because I thought I should and didn’t have the time and resources to discuss actual removal of the box with the design team.

    However, NONE of these are sold links. We own them or a portion of them and we editorial choose to link to them.

    Brent D. Payne
    SEO Manager
    Tribune

  2. CVOS Says:

    Hi Brent – this is nothing personal. My problem is with Google and their inconsistent method of dealing with penalties that never favors the little guy like Donna’s example.

    Feel free to post screenshots, I’m happy to upddate this post.

  3. Brent D. Payne Says:

    But they did penalize Newsday and it took us ‘a big guy’ months to convince them to remove it. I started working on it in February when I got to Tribune.

    Newsday nor Tribune received any penalty warning either and we did all the steps we were suppose to do.

    It’s not about the big guy versus the little guy. It’s about a slowed process of forgiveness and lack of communication from Google to the ‘offending sites’. This needs to be vastly improved. What good is a penalty warning if Google doesn’t use it?

    Brent D. Payne
    SEO Manager
    Tribune

  4. Sean Maguire Says:

    I love when someone blogs as if they know what the hell is going on, without doing any research.

    “This is nothing personal Brent…”

    What’s nothing personal? That you’re erroneously slandering a Chicago Tribune property by calling them a link seller without even checking to see if your careless assumptions are factual?

    Well, they’re not factual, so if I were you, I’d issue an apology to your community of readers for publishing bullshit and I’d retract the erroneous elements in this post.

  5. CVOS Says:

    Brent, it looks like Google was extremely kind to you & Newsday, it took less than 1 week to get fixed using Google groups.

    Sean I suggest you read the post & links before commenting.

  6. Annett Blixt Says:

    Well I agree with stopping link brokering, but who needs this with social media?

  7. Norbert Zirkind Says:

    Well I agree with this stuff. Keep it up.

  8. MaDaK Says:

    I really liked your blog quite informative and interesting facts and figures you have, we tried to sell links in the past and were successful.

  9. sam auto Says:

    Thank your for shareing the problems of getting into a google penalty and how to get out of one.

  10. bymadak Says:

    I can’t believe a major newspaper tried to sell text link ads.

  11. Chodorov Says:

    The newspaper media for the Cell phone market is growing exponentially with every single new day. Most of us pick up announcements of new events through our phones, and search rankings for news sites will cease to matter.

  12. aaron wingate Says:

    It is very nice to see second generation bloggers making an effort to make the web more useful with higher quality links and better content. Hopefully the days of mega sites selling links is over.

  13. kelly Says:

    Getting more backlinks is very important for Search Engine Optimization. While you can always buy backlinks from other webmasters, the easiest way to get backlinks is to comment on other blogs with your url. However finding blogs in your niche and then commenting is a tedious job and takes a lot of time.

  14. KelleyBDriscoll Says:

    I have not checked News corp for some time as I thought it was getting boring, but the last handful of articles are good, much better than being a link broker.

  15. Gabrielson Herold Says:

    That is the type of info that are supposed to be shared across the net, too bad the newspaper got penalized.

  16. mazen Says:

    I can’t believe a major newspaper tried to sell text link ads.

  17. graycat Says:

    There are several reasons why large properties abuse their link equity, but selling links is the worst offense.

Leave a Reply